Eliot Lefebvre ([info]lostfactor) wrote,

State of the 'Craft

So, we're at almost-release-time for Wrath of the Lich King, and while things are doubtlessly going to change over the next month I think all of they "hey boy wow" bits have dropped by now. Numbers will be tweaked, but the core of what's coming is there. And so I sit back, think, and ask myself - where am I going? Where are my favorite characters going to be when this is all said and done?

Micharan is going to be in a pretty good place. She honestly went in the opposite of the direction I thought she would - rather than getting more DPS, she got more pure utility, but I'm hardly complaining. Her DPS will be solid and versatile, and her healing and replenishment abilities will be well-loved. Not to mention that she'll have honest-to-anything crowd control capacity, which just plain makes me happy. If anything, I'm unhappy about the fact that I think her build at the moment is getting just a bit more filler than I would like and not enough real hard-hitting awesomeness. Play will be required to tweak it, but it is an ultimately minor complaint amidst a sea of being happy with where she is. She will, undeniably, be viable for small and large groups, which is where I wanted her to be but never actually expected her.

Truce, on the flipside, is not quite in a place I like. Which is strange, ultimately, because I've been liking the direction they've been going with her talents and abilities overall. My main things that I don't like aren't about damage, really. She looks more than fine there, and being able to get some more spellcasting out of her is nice. It's just subtle stuff here and there:

  • Feral Spirits doesn't feel like an Enhancement talent. It feels like something for Elemental. I got my new melee strike, I can't complain about that and I won't, but Feral Spirits just feels... strange. Important but not really meshing.
  • There isn't a compelling reason to aim for melee stats over spell ones. Okay, there is, but with the push for Shocks and Lightning Bolt/Chain Lightning to be a part of our rotation comes a question of how much is the shaman really relying on that spellcasting? I think we would sort of be in a better place if Lava Burst really didn't work so much as a damage spell as a trigger for Elemental Devestation.
  • Static Shock just isn't good enough for its placement and cost. I had been thinking that when it first came out, but I figured that there would eventually be a chance bump or an "on crit" effect. Neither happened, and it doesn't feel quite like it justifies its place there. That might just be me.
Having said all that, I like the increased synergy of abilities and the actual purpose to having different weapon enchantments, not to mention that we get a form of crowd control. Sure, it's about at Sap levels of utility, but it's better than nothing. So I'm not quite as happy with Truce as I am with Micha.

Telsa is going to be fun. Not just because she's a character whose backstory is still a secret to me, but because tanking with her promises to be odd and different and engaging. I've got ideas in my head of what it will look like, but all in all it promises to be an experience unique to tanks. I can't quite explain why I'd rather do Frost with her rather than another option, except that I'm not much of a pet person and I have people who heavy physical DPS already. Frost seems a bit more unique, in context.

Kirlia has been getting pretty much an unabated string of love this whole time. When she is not being distracted by shiny things, she will be well served by her talents. I continue speccing Arcane because, well, it's the strangest tree and it's the one that I like the most. Fire would probably work better for what I use her for, sure, but why would I break the trend?

And... then there are a bunch of other characters that don't quite make top-billing for various reasons. Chiefly my warrior and "pet vendor" (okay, he's a hunter, but he's got a real Elim Garak routine going).

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 4 comments

[info]laudre

October 5 2008, 04:40:42 UTC 3 years ago

Maelstrom Weapon no longer enables instant-cast LvB; while the numbers were never really there to push caster gear and fast Flametongued caster daggers over melee gear and slow WF MH/fast FT OH, that it was even something that could be discussed as viable -- and did well enough for some people to not switch back out right away -- showed that something was wrong. The tooltip for the latest build doesn't reflect this, but it is the case on the beta servers. This change will push us back to melee stats and damage being the lion's share of our DPS, which was the goal, but there are many who (as you allude to) suggest that the damage coefficient for LvB be nerfed and then fold a re-buffing back to the higher coefficient into a deep elemental talent (Lava Flows, most likely).

I agree that Static Shock is underwhelming; I'm on the fence about Improved Stormstrike. I'm going to have to do some more number crunching and PTR rotation testing to see if the more frequent bursts are worth the two talent points and cooldown clipping. I'm still seeing issues with a Reverberation build, even with the Earth Shock glyph.

[info]lostfactor

October 5 2008, 14:07:12 UTC 3 years ago

You misunderstood my phrasing. I was saying that we might be in a better place if they had kept Lava Burst in Maelstrom Weapon and it did just basically provide a straight Elemental Devastation uptime. In other words, spell damage and such would strictly be a bonus to what we were already doing with crit. Admittedly, the permanent 9% crit bonus may have been a factor in this.

I haven't done any number crunching on most of this because, honestly, I don't need it. There is the vague possibility that Improved Stormstrike could provide slightly improved DPS because of the reduced cooldown, but there is no time in my career as Enhancement that I've really found myself thinking "gee, I don't have anything to press at the moment." Adding Lava Lash in the rotation along with other spells just confirms that. The debuff remains fairly lackluster, and I can't see four charges on it being in any way usable in eight seconds.

There might be some slight DPS gain, sure. I don't care enough about that marginal difference to spend time on math for it.

[info]laudre

October 5 2008, 17:28:59 UTC 3 years ago

The builds over at Elitist Jerks all use Improved Stormstrike, so I'm assuming that the napkin math and sim results support it. Wouldn't be for the charges, though; the nerf to have Stormstrike charges only burnable by the originating shaman makes it extremely unlikely to burn all four charges even in the debuff's full duration. A Reverberation build could conceivably do it (there'd be just enough time to get out three Earth Shocks in the 12 seconds -- SS at 0:00.0, ES at 0:01.5, 0:06.5, and 0:11.5, plus a Maelstrom Weapon stack burned for LB/CL or a Static Shock proc), but then you'd be giving up a second SS attack, which would be utterly pointless.

Anyway, quick napkin math says that you'd be getting 7.5 Stormstrikes per minute with ISS, assuming you're using it every time the CD is up, vs. 6 without. That's 25% more damage from Stormstrike; given the percentage of damage typical from Stormstrike in our overall mix, it's a total of about a 1% DPS gain for two talent points, in and of itself. However, the extra charges DO ensure that the debuff will effectively have 100% uptime, which means 20% more damage from Earthshock, CL/LB (depending on CDs and situation), and, if you spec into it, Static Shock (which I would only do if I had nothing better to spend it on, from a DPS standpoint -- for levelling, I'll take the utility of Improved Ghost Wolf over Static Shock, but in raiding I'd go for the extra DPS).

It's probably worth it, still; back when we could use FS/LvB to ensure 100% Elemental Devastation uptime, and when it was buffed to boost Fire and Frost, it was mandatory. (Also, Elemental Devastation is still mandatory -- it's got about 50% uptime at level 70, with an 8/53 build.) In your build above, I think I'd drop two points from Convection and put them into Improved Stormstrike; the mana efficiency from Elemental Focus and Shamanistic Focus, the MP5 from Water Shield, and Shamanistic Rage should be plenty to keep from OOM in a long enough fight for it to matter (and you would probably have Mana Spring Totem down, and a party member capable of providing mana replenishment).

[info]thefreefall

October 14 2008, 01:15:06 UTC 3 years ago

Divine Storm is ridiculously fun. Did it on the beta with a premade Draenei pally... made me want one.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…